The Product Rule: Why You Can’t Just Multiply Two Derivatives
When you differentiate a product of two functions, f(x)·g(x), you can’t just multiply f'(x) by g'(x) — that gives the wrong answer almost every time. Instead, the Product Rule says: d/dx[f·g] = f′g + fg′. In words: take the derivative of the first function times the second, plus the first function times the derivative of the second.
d/dx[f·g] = f′g + fg′ — think ‘first times derivative of second, plus second times derivative of first’ (say it like a little rhyme until it sticks).
The intuition behind f′g + fg′
- 💡 Picture a rectangle with sides f(x) and g(x) — its area is f·g.
- 🎯 If both sides are changing, the area changes in two ways: because f is growing (f′·g) AND because g is growing (f·g′).
- ✅ Add both effects together — that’s exactly the Product Rule formula.
One memorable line: the rectangle grows from both edges at once, so you add both contributions.
Where students lose points
- ❌ Multiplying f′(x) · g′(x) — this is NOT the derivative of a product.
- ❌ Forgetting to keep the original (non-derivative) function in each term.
- ❌ Dropping a term entirely when g(x) is a constant (remember: derivative of a constant is 0, so that whole term vanishes — but don’t forget the other one).
- ✅ Always write both terms first, then simplify.
Differentiate y = x² · sin(x)
- Let f(x) = x² → f′(x) = 2x
- Let g(x) = sin(x) → g′(x) = cos(x)
- Apply the rule: y′ = f′g + fg′
- y′ = (2x)(sin x) + (x²)(cos x)
✅ Final answer: y′ = 2x·sin(x) + x²·cos(x)
Two different jobs
- 🎯 Product Rule: use when two separate functions are multiplied — f(x)·g(x).
- 🎯 Chain Rule: use when one function is nested inside another — f(g(x)).
- 💡 Quick test: can you rewrite the expression as ‘this times that’? Product Rule. Is it ‘this, plugged into that’? Chain Rule.
- ✅ Many real problems need both rules together — that’s normal, not a sign you’re doing something wrong.
Copy-paste recipe
- 1️⃣ Identify f(x) and g(x) — the two pieces being multiplied.
- 2️⃣ Find f′(x) and g′(x) separately.
- 3️⃣ Plug into:
f′(x)·g(x) + f(x)·g′(x) - 4️⃣ Simplify if possible.
💡 Keep this four-step recipe taped above your desk until it’s automatic.


